BLUEPRINT

Advertiser Disclosure

Editorial Note: Blueprint may earn a commission from affiliate partner links featured here on our site. This commission does not influence our editors' opinions or evaluations. Please view our full advertiser disclosure policy.

“You snooze, you lose” could very well apply to small businesses with critical open jobs to fill. The best applicant tracking systems make sure you’re able to find and assess qualified candidates simply and quickly — without having to settle for less than the best people.

The 10 best applicant tracking systems we identified stand out from the pack for a variety of reasons. Some boost the hiring team’s ability to collaborate and others make fast work (literally) of your recruiting and hiring processes. We assessed these companies based on value, features and customer support so you can make an informed decision on which one is the most suitable for your business.

Best applicant tracking systems

  • Manatal: Best for AI-based candidate assessments.
  • Workable: Best for hiring-team collaboration.
  • HiringThing: Best private-label solution for recruiters and agencies.
  • Zoho Recruit: Best for automated recruiting and hiring.
  • Recruit CRM: Best for candidate matching.
  • Ceipal: Best for diversity hiring.
  • iCIMS: Best for international recruiting.
  • JazzHR: Easiest to use.
  • PCRecruiter: Best for capturing candidate data.
  • Jobvite: Best for creating branded career sites.

Why trust our small business experts

Our team of experts evaluates hundreds of business products and analyzes thousands of data points to help you find the best product for your situation. We use a data-driven methodology to determine each rating. Advertisers do not influence our editorial content. You can read more about our methodology below.

  • 25 companies reviewed.
  • 2,336 data points analyzed.
  • 100+ hours of research.

Best applicant tracking systems comparison

PAID PLAN PRICINGINTERVIEW SCHEDULINGANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGSKILLS ASSESSMENTJOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTBACKGROUND CHECKSONBOARDINGDOCUMENT MANAGEMENTINTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICS
$19 to $59 per user per monthYesNoYes; third-party add-onsYesNoYesYesYes
PAID PLAN PRICING$19 to $59 per user per month
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGNo
SKILLS ASSESSMENTYes; third-party add-ons
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTYes
BACKGROUND CHECKSNo
ONBOARDINGYes
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTYes
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes
$149 to $2,507 per monthYesYesYesYesYes; third-party add-onsStandard and Premier onlyYesYes
PAID PLAN PRICING$149 to $2,507 per month
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGYes
SKILLS ASSESSMENTYes
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTYes
BACKGROUND CHECKSYes; third-party add-ons
ONBOARDINGStandard and Premier only
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTYes
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes
From $73 per monthYesNoYes; third-party add-onsYesYes; third-party add-onsYesYesYes
PAID PLAN PRICINGFrom $73 per month
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGNo
SKILLS ASSESSMENTYes; third-party add-ons
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTYes
BACKGROUND CHECKSYes; third-party add-ons
ONBOARDINGYes
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTYes
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes
$30 to $90 per month per userYesNoYesNoYes; third-party add-onsYesNoYes
PAID PLAN PRICING$30 to $90 per month per user
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGNo
SKILLS ASSESSMENTYes
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTNo
BACKGROUND CHECKSYes; third-party add-ons
ONBOARDINGYes
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTNo
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes

$100 to $150 per user per month
YesNoNoYesNoNoYesYes
PAID PLAN PRICING
$100 to $150 per user per month
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGNo
SKILLS ASSESSMENTNo
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTYes
BACKGROUND CHECKSNo
ONBOARDINGNo
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTYes
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes
$24 per month per userYesNoYes; third-party add-onsYesYes; third-party add-onsYesYesYes
PAID PLAN PRICING$24 per month per user
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGNo
SKILLS ASSESSMENTYes; third-party add-ons
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTYes
BACKGROUND CHECKSYes; third-party add-ons
ONBOARDINGYes
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTYes
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes
Contact companyYesNoYes; third-party add-onsYesYes; third-party add-onsYesYesYes
PAID PLAN PRICINGContact company
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGNo
SKILLS ASSESSMENTYes; third-party add-ons
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTYes
BACKGROUND CHECKSYes; third-party add-ons
ONBOARDINGYes
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTYes
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes
$99 to $499 per monthYesYes; third-party add-onsYes; third-party add-onsYesYes; third-party add-onsYesYesYes
PAID PLAN PRICING$99 to $499 per month
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGYes; third-party add-ons
SKILLS ASSESSMENTYes; third-party add-ons
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTYes
BACKGROUND CHECKSYes; third-party add-ons
ONBOARDINGYes
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTYes
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes
From $85 per user per monthYes; third-party add-onsNoNoYesNoNoNoYes
PAID PLAN PRICINGFrom $85 per user per month
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes; third-party add-ons
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGNo
SKILLS ASSESSMENTNo
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTYes
BACKGROUND CHECKSNo
ONBOARDINGNo
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTNo
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes
Contact companyYesNoYes; third-party add-onsNoYes; third-party add-onsYesNoYes
PAID PLAN PRICINGContact company
INTERVIEW SCHEDULINGYes
ANONYMOUS CANDIDATE SCREENINGNo
SKILLS ASSESSMENTYes; third-party add-ons
JOB REQUISITION MANAGEMENTNo
BACKGROUND CHECKSYes; third-party add-ons
ONBOARDINGYes
DOCUMENT MANAGEMENTNo
INTEGRATED REPORTING AND ANALYTICSYes

Methodology

We extensively research the key competitors within an industry to determine the best products and services for your business. Our experts identify the factors that matter most to business owners, including pricing, features and customer support, to ensure that our recommendations offer well-rounded products that will meet the needs of various small businesses.

We collect extensive data to narrow our best list to reputable, easy-to-use products with stand-out features at a reasonable price point. And we look at user reviews to ensure that business owners like you are satisfied with our top picks’ services. We use the same rubric to assess companies within a particular space so you can confidently follow our blueprint to the best applicant tracking systems of 2024.

Expert score (10%): The factors considered in determining our expert score for applicant tracking systems balance each product’s features, value, popularity and ease of use, each of which accounts for 2.5% of the total score in this category. In particular, we identify the core features required by small businesses and how well the products return a company’s investment in them.

Value (36%): The most important aspects in evaluating the ability of applicant tracking systems to benefit a business’ bottom line are their cost per recruiter, number of active job postings and the availability and length of free trial periods. Whether the product’s prices are posted doesn’t factor into our value calculations.

Features (44%): The bulk of our assessment is based on each product’s range of features. These include integrations with third-party job boards, job posts to social media and the availability of interviewing scheduling tools, including self-scheduling for job candidates. Other important features are resume parsing, communication with applicants and job pipeline automation tools.

Service and support (10%): Vendor support scores are determined by the company’s telephone and live chat support hours, responsiveness to email support requests and provision of self-help resources such as knowledge bases, video tutorials and community forums.

What is an applicant tracking system (ATS), and how does it work?

An ATS is a software used to help with tracking and managing job candidates. Features typically include automated emails and SMS messages, analytics, applicant tracking tools and resume parsing. The aim of an ATS is so that HR teams and recruiters can streamline their current workflows and make the hiring process more efficient. 

Some businesses also want to ensure they remain compliant when recruiting candidates, and an ATS can help. This type of software usually won’t help you create your own online platform. Businesses and recruiters who want to appear more legitimate to potential candidates should consider using a website creation platform.

Benefits of applicant tracking systems

Recruiting candidates for open positions requires deliberation to ensure you’re finding and attracting the most qualified candidates, but it also has to be done quickly to keep your business running on all cylinders.

Applicant tracking systems help companies meet these two contrasting goals by providing tools that surface the best applicants and automate the gathering and assessing of candidate information. They assist with hiring decisions and bringing new staff on board.

  • Automated job posting. Applicant tracking systems provide templates for writing effective job ads and link automatically to popular free and paid job boards.
  • Resume parsing. The products automatically scan applicants’ resumes, cover letters and other submitted material to match attributes and skills with those required by each open position.
  • Cross-functional collaboration. By creating a central, shared portal for tracking applicants through the hiring pipeline, the systems make it easy for stakeholders in various roles and departments to communicate clearly and in a timely manner.
  • Enhanced candidate experience. Applicants’ first impression of a potential employer comes from their interaction with its recruiting and hiring process. By personalizing communication and putting tools in candidates’ hands, they become empowered and excited about joining your organization.
  • More effective recruiting. The old saying, “Time is money” has never been truer, and for small businesses and HR departments, the less time they spend handling administrative tasks, the more time they can devote to getting to know and learning about job candidates.

How to choose the best applicant tracking system

Before shopping for an applicant tracking system for your business, you have to understand the strengths and weaknesses of your current recruiting and hiring pipeline, and the technology available to enhance those operations. Once you’ve got a budget and features list in hand, you’re ready to determine the product that best combines functionality and affordability.

Key features to look for

The individual features of applicant tracking systems work together to create a seamless recruiting and hiring pipeline that’s accessible to all parties involved with making hiring decisions. These are key components of a small business recruitment and onboarding platform.

  • Automated recruiting workflows. Many applicant tracking vendors apply AI to replace manual processes with tools that screen volumes of resumes automatically and enhance interactions with job candidates.
  • Applicant search and candidate matching. AI is also being applied to do more than simply scan resumes and other candidate information for matches to a single job. It also helps to surface skills and capabilities that may apply to other open positions or to jobs that may become available in the future.
  • Analytics and reporting. Applicant tracking systems support key performance indicators for your company’s recruiting and hiring processes. These include time to hire, time to fill, cost per hire, selection ratio, attrition, application completion rate and offer acceptance rate.
  • Integration with existing work processes. One of the factors that slows hiring is the delay in handoffs throughout the process. Applicant tracking systems allow all parties involved in hiring to see at a glance the status of recruiting and hiring efforts in addition to tasks awaiting their attention.
  • Links to third-party job boards. The most efficient and feature-packed applicant tracking system won’t get your company’s open jobs filled unless they make your positions discoverable by the most qualified candidates. To do that, they need to post job openings to popular job boards, such as ZipRecruiter, LinkedIn, Indeed and Careerbuilder.
  • Collaboration tools. In addition to integrating with your business’ email and text systems, applicant tracking tools need to serve as the nexus for all interactions between stakeholders in the recruiting and hiring process. They do so by providing centralized, shared workspaces that make information easy to access.
  • Customizations. The best applicant tracking systems are able to conform to your company’s way of doing business, including its internal and external operations.
  • Compliance and security. For organizations that operate in multiple countries and jurisdictions, the systems need to keep them apprised of all applicable regulations relating to recruiting and hiring by location. This includes General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) requirements for EU countries and state regulations such as the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA).

Add-ons and extras

While many applicant tracking systems are sold as all-in-one solutions, such as Manatal and Jobvite, others take a cafeteria approach, allowing businesses to start with a base plan and add the features they need for an added charge.

For example, Workable’s applicant tracking plans include “core recruiting features” but require an additional fee for texting, video interviews and assessments. Similarly, JazzHR sells three plans priced from $99 a month to $499 a month, but candidate texting costs from $39 a month on top of that for all three; Zoom integration (from $29 a month) as well as advanced visual reporting (from $59 a month) are sold separately. 

Customer service

Many of the negative reviews of applicant tracking systems posted by users on sites such as Capterra and G2 relate to the poor quality of the support operations of many vendors. For example, of the services we reviewed, only Recruit CRM provides 24/7 live chat support for all plans. Zoho Recruit offers 24/7 telephone support only for its Enterprise plan customers, and 24/5 telephone support for its other packages. Manatal also has 24/5 support through chat and email.

How much does an applicant tracking system cost?

FOREVER FREE PLAN AVAILABLE?BASE PLAN (PER MONTH)MID-TIER PLAN (PER MONTH)HIGH-TIER PLAN (PER MONTH)FREE TRIAL
Manatal
No
Professional: $19 per user
Enterprise: $39 per user
Enterprise Plus: $59 per user
14 days
Workable
No
Starter: $149
Standard: $378
Premier: $628
15 days
HiringThing
No
$73
N/A
N/A
14 days
Zoho Recruit
Yes
Standard: $30 per user
Professional: $60 per user
Enterprise: $90 per user
15 days
Recruit CRM
No
Pro: $100 per user
Business: $150 per user
Enterprise: $165 per user
Unlimited
Ceipal
No
$24 per user
N/A
N/A
14 days
iCIMS
No
N/A
N/A
N/A
None
JazzHR
No
Hero: $99
Plus: $325
Pro: $499
14 days
PCRecruiter
No
$85 per user
N/A
N/A
None
Jobvite
No
N/A
N/A
N/A
None

The applicant tracking systems sold by the vendors in our review are priced from $30 per user each month to several hundred dollars a month. Nearly all of the vendors in our review give businesses discounts of 10% to 20% for signing an annual contract. 

However, many of the plans sold by applicant tracking vendors exclude some useful features that are offered as add-ons such as candidate texting and Zoom integration.

What we don’t recommend

Many of the same vendors that touted their products’ ability to get a business’ jobs posted and filled quickly were slow in responding to our requests for information. In many instances, we made repeated attempts to contact the companies by phone, chat, email and web form only to receive no response after five business days, which we considered to be an unacceptable wait.

Applicant tracking systems are typically not simple to implement because of two factors: The products have to integrate with your company’s existing processes, and your employees and managers have to learn how to use their many features, which usually cover everything from writing or updating the job descriptions to onboarding new hires.

Considering the time required to fill an open position, your organization will be dealing with multi-step workflows involving many roles within and outside the company. Be sure to thoroughly vet your chosen vendor to ensure they’ll be able to provide adequate support.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

Yes, there are free applicant tracking systems available. Some offer free tiers (with limited features) or a free trial for you to test out their ATS. Examples include Zoho Recruit, which has a Forever Free plan and Recruit CRM, which has an unlimited free trial.

An ATS can be worth it for small businesses, especially if your staff is already stretched thin. Integrating an ATS into your workflow can help automate manual tasks that would have taken longer to complete, thereby helping you to cut down on labor and recruiting costs.

Some benefits of applicant tracking systems include:

  • Automating tedious tasks. 
  • Selecting candidates from a large pool of applicants.
  • Remaining in compliance with any applicable laws or regulations.

Blueprint is an independent publisher and comparison service, not an investment advisor. The information provided is for educational purposes only and we encourage you to seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding specific financial decisions. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Blueprint has an advertiser disclosure policy. The opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the Blueprint editorial staff alone. Blueprint adheres to strict editorial integrity standards. The information is accurate as of the publish date, but always check the provider’s website for the most current information.

Dennis O'Reilly has more than two decades of experience writing about hardware, software and tech services for news outlets, tech sites and educational institutions. He edited PC World's Here's How section for more than seven years and was a founding member of the CNET Blog Network, where he posted hundreds of tips to help people get more out of the technology in their lives. Dennis also was the technical editor for the Windows Secrets newsletter and editorial supervisor for Ziff-Davis's Computer Select service. Dennis is a graduate of the University of Michigan and the Empire College School of Law in Santa Rosa, California. He and his wife are long-time residents of the Northern California. When he's not digging deep into the mysteries of 21st century technology, Dennis volunteers as a pro bono attorney.

Sierra Campbell is a small business editor for USA Today Blueprint. She specializes in writing, editing and fact-checking content centered around helping businesses. She has worked as a digital content and show producer for several local TV stations, an editor for U.S. News & World Report and a freelance writer and editor for many companies. Sierra prides herself in delivering accurate and up-to-date information to readers. Her expertise includes credit card processing companies, e-commerce platforms, payroll software, accounting software and virtual private networks (VPNs). She also owns Editing by Sierra, where she offers editing services to writers of all backgrounds, including self-published and traditionally published authors.